Water Welders is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Does Welding Weaken Steel? (2021)

Last Updated on

Welder-test-with-gas-tungsten-arc-welding_Funtay_shutterstock

 

When welding, one of the crucial things you should think about is if the metal you’re using when will become flimsy when you connect it with another metal.

So, does steel become weak if you use it in welding? Yes, welding makes steel weak, especially in the HAZ (heat-affected zone) if you weld at high temperatures. Weakening when it comes to welding is usual with chilly-rolled steel.

When connecting distinct metals, you can use three main methods:

  • Welding
  • Brazing
  • Soldering

You can apply any approach to connect metal items. There’s also a way to fill in the gaps in the metal components. If you utilize welding, the two metals must be similar. For instance, you cannot weld steel to copper. In this article, we’ll look at several facts on if welding makes steel feeble.


So, Does Welding Make Steel Flimsy?

Welding weakens steel. If metal is exposed to a temperature alteration via the heat transfer zones, the metal changes physically. The size of its grains and the crystalline structure change unless it has a mono-structure such as glass.

If metal is subjected to too much heat, its strength lessens. It also becomes soft and increases ductility. On the other hand, metal can become harder and brittle.

pipe_welding

Image Credit: sumanamul15, Pixabay

HAZ (Heat-Affected Zone)

There’s always a heat-affected zone when welding. Whatever happens at the heat-affected area relies on the parent metal’s temperature that it’s predisposed to in the welding procedure and the travel velocity (fast or gradual) of cooling soon after the weld joint has turned into solid.

Shrinkage of the weld joint and mechanical damage can occur from heat gradients in the workpiece. It may lead to strains, tears, warping, and even micro-fissures. You can take precautions like restricting the heat output, preheating the workpieces, and post-weld heat treatments.

Besides, you can use welding fixtures that have chill blocks, apply post-heat (blanket, oven, or torch), gradual cooling, or quenching. All of them depend on the procedure and the material.

Limb, crucial welds, worthy property, or welds where failure can cause loss of life, have to be carried out by approved welders and authorized gear, using standards and processes certified by reputable welding engineering approval groups like the American Welding Society.

When it comes to welding exotic alloys or several metals that are not common, special welding processes have to be followed for the specific application and weld joint. Also, it must be certified by a competent welding technician.

These kinds of welds have to be carried out by a welder who is approved for that specific welding procedure. They’ll comprehend the materials needed, the type of joint, and the position of the weld.

A qualified welder can also regulate the amount of heat applied to the weld. This way, steel won’t become weak when welding.

Welding Effects and Approaches used to Strengthen Steel

Welding-with-sparks-by-Process-fluxed-cored-arc-welding_YAKISTUDIO_shutterstock

Image Credit: YAKISTUDIO, Shutterstock

The heat-affected zone (HAZ) is the only steel area that can be influenced negatively or positively by welding. Supposing that you have used the correct filler metal, the heat-affected zone is the metal area to be impacted.

The filler metal doesn’t undergo recrystallization. Therefore, it remains as potent as the parent metal. The only area that’ll be affected is the heat-affected zone. It’s because of the factors we’ve mentioned above.

Usually, this happens if you’re using cold-rolled steel in welding. When working with this type of steel, then the joints’ design is crucial. Also, it’ll be essential to factor in the strain level the piece will undergo when welding.

It’s crucial to note that, when welding, the higher the amount of heat you use, the quicker the rate of the metal becoming weak. In some instances, you can correct a post-welding defect if you use the correct heat treatment.

What Are the Advantages of Heat Treatment in Preventing Steel from Becoming Weak?

One effective way of strengthening a steel weld joint is using post-weld approaches and heat treatment. It’s because it controls the bainite that may form in the heat-affected zone.

It frees areas that could potentially lead to a fissure with time if subjected to stress. The correct heat treatment can alter the grain size, hardness, strength of the tensile, and toughness. It can enhance magnetic and electrical qualities, elasticity, and ease strain.

Comprehending how to perform heat treatment well is essential. It helps you get the maximum advantage. It’s not just using a torch when it comes to steel and then allowing the material to cool down.

You need to comprehend and carry out factors such as the temperature of the heat you’re using, the rate of cooling, and the time it takes. Also, you need to know the materials used, and how they’ll be effective.

arc welding-pixabay2

Image Credit: samjok5, Pixabay

It’s crucial to know that there are several ways you can do this. Some examples comprise melted metal bath, innate gas, electrically heated salt, induction heating, and oxy-fuel or fuel-air torches. Most of the regulated cooling methods may comprise cooling the metal in the sand, water or fan cooling, furnace cooling, and even utilizing still air.

If you want to get the results you desire, the crucial aspect is regulating the cooling and heating procedure. These factors play a crucial role in ascertaining whether welding makes steel strong or weak.

If you heat or cool steel too gradually, or apply too much heat, you’ll not achieve the desired results. If the steel is imbued in heat throughout and then gradually cooled, you can easily machine the metal.

Let’s now look at how you can prepare steel to get a heat treatment (normalizing).

What is Normalizing?

If you want to prepare steel to get future heat treatment, the process is known as normalizing. It assists in restructuring the metal’s internal aspects and, therefore, lessens the impact of interior strain.

You can use this procedure to soften the metal. However, it stops it from softening more like it would without the process. If you apply thermal methods, it’ll heat the spot where stress can occur. Then, it’ll cool gradually.

This way, the metal changes to mitigate the stressors placed on it. If you want to perform this procedure with steel, you’ll need a temperature of around 1,100 degrees Fahrenheit. At times, the temperature may reach up to 1,150 degrees Fahrenheit. Professionals have found out that temperatures can decrease the damage caused through stress by up to 80%.

welder-helmet-pixabay

Image Credit: wyllyston, Pixabay

Prevent Weakening of Steel Effectively

High-strength steel can become weak because of welding. You should seek expert advice on the stresses allowed on the metal. We hope that this article has been helpful to you now that you know how to prevent steel from weakening.


Featured Image: Funtay, Shutterstock

Cameron Dekker
 

Cameron grew up in Allentown, Pennsylvania, a once-proud steel town on the Lehigh River, where he got a taste of TIG welding in his high school shop class. He holds certificates for Certified WeldingEducator (CWE) and Certified Resistance Welding Technician (CRWT) from the American Welding Institute. His interests include scuba diving, sculpture, and kayaking.